‘Snakes and Earrings’ by Hitomi Kanehara **

Snakes and Earrings is a short novella written by Hitomi Kanehara and it has won the Akutagawa Literary Prize in 2003, one of the most prestigious and well-recognised literary prizes in Japan. The story revolves around Lui, a nineteen-year-old girl who, after meeting Ama, a guy whose body is full of tattoos and who also has a snake-like forked tongue, becomes mesmerised by this body transfiguration process and embarks on a journey to evoke it on her own body as well.

922711I was initially quite excited to read this novella, as the plot sounded rather intriguing and I had also heard it being praised by some literary people I admire and respect. Haruki Murakami’s brother, Ryu Murakami (whose writing is rather darker and more provoking than his world-famous brother’s) was a member of the critics team who chose the Akutagawa Prize winner and he characteristically said that Kanehara’s story was immediately recognised as the best among all works that had been submitted for the prize that year – a statement which certainly creates some expectations and raises the bar at a rather high level.

To my own disappointment, however, this book was nowhere near as good and gripping as I expected it to be. The writing seemed flat and immature, the dialogues were rather poorly written (one could argue that they were ‘realistic’) and I could not like or even empathise with a single character throughout the entire story. There is some mystery towards the end of the book, when a murder occurs and the plot gets a bit more complicated, but it sadly was not anything mind-blowing.

I understand that this book is targeted towards and tackles the issues of a specific generation of Japanese youth, but it just did not work for me. Instead of feeling the struggles of the characters and the hardships they had to overcome I only kept thinking how all the characters in this book belong to a specific category of people (the ‘rebels’ or ‘non-conformists’ or however you want to call them) who had nothing to do in their lives and just let their time slip away with drinking, having sex and the like.

Another issue I had with this book were the descriptions of the processes of getting different parts of your body pierced or stretched or, even worse, split, like Ama’s forked tongue. Now, I’m a very squirmish person when it comes to graphic descriptions of the sort, and so I really did not appreciate the way in which the author seemed to describe those processes, as if she was talking about a simple recipe or something.

Since it is a very short book (my edition was 126 pages) and not difficult at all, it makes for a very quick read. I can see why this book may have caused an uproar as a shocking tale, but I believe it had more problems than redeeming qualities for it to become such a best-seller and a prize winning novel. I admit it kept me thinking about the events and the characters for a quite a while after I read it, but the feelings it left me with were pretty much those of sadness at the realisation for one more time that this world can be such a dark and desperate place and disappointment because I expected so much more from this story.

I read this book as part of the 20 Books of Summer challenge and the Japanese Literature Challenge 9.

20-books-of-summer-master-image

jlc9

Advertisements

10 thoughts on “‘Snakes and Earrings’ by Hitomi Kanehara **

  1. Pingback: 20 Books of Summer Wrap-up (Akylina) | theliterarysisters

  2. Oh dear – sounds very disappointing, and not one I think I would like either. It’s always a shame when you’re expecting to enjoy a book!

    • That’s so true, Kaggsy! It was so highly praised that I never expected it to be like that. If you ever decide to read it, do let me know what you think 🙂

  3. I watched the film version of this first – which I liked, which is why I decided to pick up the book but as I rememer it I found it too “simple”? Basically the themes are all the same as the film, but I found the story was better told through a film format. Of course it’s been several years since I watched the film and read the book, I own the book so I’m curious to see how I would feel about it now. Interesting to read your thoughts!

    • I haven’t watched the film yet – maybe the film format indeed gives the story more justice than the book did. It certainly was too “simple”. I felt like I understood the messages it wanted to convey but I don’t think it managed to it that well. Thank you for sharing your thoughts about it 🙂 I hope the film proves to be much better.

  4. Never heard of this novella before and I thought I’m beginning to get the hang of Japanese literature and the big names involved. I have a pretty strong stomach so I don’t think the body modifications would bother me, but I don’t think this is for me. I’m just too old and jaded to read about angsty non-conformist teens.

    Thanks for the informative review! 🙂

  5. Thank you for your honest review! I borrowed this recently from my local library but never ended up reading it. I think the thought of the forked tongue makes me uncomfortable. However, I know what I’m like and will probably borrow it again at some point!
    Also, I didn’t know the two Murakami’s were brothers. I have a friend with that name so I assumed it was reasonably common. Unless my friend has kept quiet about being related to them 🙂

  6. Pingback: The Good, the Bad and the Unfinished of 2015 | theliterarysisters

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s